Forest Service Sides With Alta Snowboarding Ban

In the ongoing battle over the Alta snowboarding ban the US Forest Service has sided with the ski resort, essentially arguing that snowboarders’ mere presence on a ski hill presents a “legitimate safety concern” for skiers above and beyond the risk posed by other skiers. While there may be discriminatory or differential treatment, the Forest Service concludes that the Alta snowboarding ban is not “irrational” and further that these “concerns that can be avoided or minimized by not allowing snowboarders.”

A skier enjoys the Alta snowboarding ban

But the argument that Alta is a safer resort for skiers because they don’t allow snowboarding simply does not hold up under scrutiny.

In a filing last week, Alta attorneys explained that skiers find the slopes at Alta more peaceful, safe and enjoyable because they don’t have to worry about being hit by snowboarders whose sideways stance leaves them with a blind spot that can make their wide, sweeping turns a danger to others on the slopes.

Well, if there’s a “safety” concern, it is purely imaginary; the product of a decades-old stereotype and Alta’s marketing department (after all, perception is reality…). In fact, regardless of fault, skiers are disproportionately more likely to collide with other skiers, than they are to collide with snowboarders. Jasper Shealy’s research for the National Ski Area Association has found that skiers are three times more likely than snowboarders to be involved in collisions with others.

What do you think about the Alta snowboarding ban?

Should snowboards continue to be prohibited on the USFS land that Alta leases from the Federal Government? Does snowboarding pose inherent risks to skiers?


One thought on “Forest Service Sides With Alta Snowboarding Ban

  1. I think the Forest Service would rather all folks stay out of their forests than add to it by siding against Alta.

    When I started skiing Snowboarders bothered me and not so much on the trails, but around the lifts. Now they have either learned to move away from the lifts more before getting ready for the next run or I can simply navigate around them better.

    Any interest in this case I have is from my general political outlook and is something I keep separate from my snow writing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Connect with Facebook

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>